TysonSullivan
May 27, 2026
"I was disappointed with this. The toppings tasted..."
I was disappointed with this. The toppings tasted like they’d been sitting around for a while, and the veggies were limp instead of crisp. It also had this weird, empty feel to it, like no real person had put much care into making it. Overall, not something I’d want to order again.
Julie.waters
May 01, 2026
"Pizza was okay, like nothing really bad about..."
Pizza was okay, like nothing really bad about it, but for the price I was expecting a little more. It felt like decent slice, just not worth paying that much for it
JesseDiaz_15
April 30, 2026
"I ordered from Pepper Pizza expecting something..."
I ordered from Pepper Pizza expecting something decent, especially based on how it was presented online, but I felt misled once the food arrived.
The pizza showed up late and was only just warm. The toppings looked like they’d been tossed on without much care, and the crust was chewy in a bad way, not at all what I thought I was paying for.
I tried calling to sort it out, but it felt like nobody was really bothered. For the price, I expected a lot better, and I definitely won’t be ordering from them again
William_garrison78
April 28, 2026
"Decent deals, but nothing too exciting :)"
The deals were good, so that was nice! The pizza itself was just okay though, not bad, but not something I’d be rushing back for :)
"The Crust Ruined the Whole Pizza"
I ordered this thinking I was in for a solid pizza night, but wow, the crust completely betrayed the mission. It was hard, dry, and tasted like it had been sitting around way too long. The toppings were fine, nothing terrible there, but the crust was so bad it pretty much stole the whole show in the worst way. I couldn’t get past it, and I definitely won’t be ordering this again.
rebecca.Holcomb
April 24, 2026
"For some reason, my pizza had barely any toppings"
I ordered a pizza from peppergourmetpizza.com.au and for some reason it showed up with hardly any toppings on it. It felt like I was mostly eating bread and cheese, which was disappointing for what I paid.
I understand businesses have costs to manage, but this just came across as really stingy. I’d probably skip ordering from there again unless they start putting a decent amount of toppings on their pizzas
AlanMcclendon_15
April 18, 2026
"I came in feeling upbeat and..."
I came in feeling upbeat and ready to enjoy my meal, but the sticky tables and dirty-looking floor kind of took me out of the mood. The food was okay, but the place could definitely use more attention to cleanliness.
CliffordHernandez
April 16, 2026
"Bland pizza and not worth the hassle"
The crust was okay, but the flavor was just off and kind of bland in a weird way. I thought about reaching out to customer service, but I don’t really trust they’d do much besides give me a generic response, so I’m just leaving the review here.
Melody.leatherman
March 26, 2026
"Took around two hours longer than expected"
My pizza ended up arriving about two hours late, and by the time it got here it was only just warm. I didn’t get any updates either, so I had to follow up myself to find out what was going on. Frustrating experience overall.
Stacy_maughan03
March 21, 2026
"Not ideal if your stomach has opinions"
I was disappointed with the dietary options. I was looking for clear info on gluten-free or dairy-free choices, but apparently that was a little too ambitious. It felt like I had to do some detective work before ordering, which is always fun when food allergies are involved.
Maybe it’s perfectly fine if you’re just ordering a regular pizza and living dangerously, but if you’ve got allergies or specific diet needs, it’s not very helpful. I didn’t feel confident enough to order in the end, so yeah, 1 star from me.
hello_charles652
January 29, 2026
"Solid pizza, but I was hoping for a little more"
I tried Pepper Gourmet Pizza it was decent. The pizza itself was good, and they’ve got the standard options you’d expect plus a couple of extras. But reading between the lines, it feels like the menu is playing it a bit safe. I was kind of hoping for more topping choices or maybe a few different pizza styles that stood out. It’s totally fine for a regular pizza night, and I’d probably order again, but I do wish there was a bit more variety to get excited about.
robertmeeks7956
January 20, 2026
"I don’t know what happened, but the pizza..."
I don’t know what happened, but the pizza I got wasn’t the one I ordered. I was really looking forward to it, and then when I opened the box... yeah, just the wrong pizza entirely.
jerome.Williams
January 18, 2026
"I ordered from Pepper Gourmet Pizza and..."
I ordered from Pepper Gourmet Pizza and it felt like the timing was just completely off. By the time the food got to me, it was cold, like it had been ready ages before it actually left or got delivered.
The pizza wasn’t even warm in the middle, and the chips had gone all soggy, which was a shame because it probably would’ve been decent if it had arrived when it should’ve. I ended up putting everything in the oven, which kind of defeats the whole point of getting takeaway.
For the price, it was disappointing. Maybe it was just bad timing that night, but I wouldn’t be in a hurry to order again.
FloydDiaz_18
January 13, 2026
"Online ordering was frustrating this time"
I’ve ordered online from plenty of places before and usually it’s straightforward, but this was a mess. The site kept glitching out, and when I finally got to checkout, it just wouldn’t work. I ended up giving up because it was way more annoying than it needed to be
Alan-dahl
December 26, 2025
"Pickup wasn’t great lol"
I ended up waiting a long time even after the pickup time, and by the time I got the pizza it was already cold. Disappointing lol, not sure I’d go back.
john1980
December 22, 2025
"First impression: the portions looked way too small"
When the pizza first showed up, my immediate thought was that it looked small for what I paid. I was hoping the taste would make up for it, and it was okay, but I still ended up feeling hungry afterward. For me, that first impression stuck, and the portion size just made it feel not really worth it.
BURDICK
December 18, 2025
"Pizza box showed up soggy tbh"
The packaging was bad ngl. By the time it got to me, the pizza box was all soggy, which was kinda disappointing...
gerald.Comstock
December 15, 2025
"Quality really depends on the day"
I’ve ordered from here a few times, it’s been hit or miss. Sometimes the food is decent, but other times it shows up soggy or just kind of bland. I’m sure other customers feel the same way, when the quality changes that much from one order to the next, it’s hard to feel confident ordering again.
nathaniel-Willingham
December 08, 2025
"First impression was fun, but a little uneven"
My first impression was that the combos looked really fun and different, which definitely made me want to try a few. Some of the toppings were interesting and worked well, but others didn’t quite come together for me. Overall, it was decent, just a bit hit or miss.